In this name-droppy (in a good way) episode, Sara and Nikki discuss the Katy Perry 3D movie experience, and then hear a wonderful tale of celebrity hijinks from Fallon warm-up and bit player Seth Herzog, and he recounts a bachelor party gone awkwardly wrong.

Welcome to Season 2 of "You Had To Be There!" Why is it season 2? Because we said so. And we think it very appropriate that our first guest for Season 2 was ALSO our first guest from Season 1! The wonderful Rachel Feinstein joins us for a discussion about the Daniel Tosh "rape joke" controversy, rape culture, girl-on-girl action, dad's, and more.

Yes! Dave Hill, the awesome comedian and musician behind the "You Had To Be There" theme song, is finally a guest on the show, providing some acoustic songs and hilarious conversation. He and the ladies discuss high school reunions, boobies, Nikki's instagram, and Dave tells one of the CRAZIEST subway stories of all time. This one is so GREAT!